New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has set aside a Rs 10 lakh penalty imposed under the Customs Act on a Ludhiana customs house agent in a case of Chinese firecrackers allegedly imported in the guise of bicycle parts, holding that there was no independent evidence against him. A Division Bench of Justice Avneesh Jhingan and Justice Shail Jain allowed the appeal of Harish Goyal (CUSAA 132/2022) on November 6, after reserving the judgment on November 2.
Goyal, proprietor of Krishna Clearing & Forwarding Agency in Ludhiana, had acted as customs house agent for M/s Rahul Traders and M/s Kirat Sales. The case arose from two containers imported under a bill of lading dated August 4, 2016, declared to hold bicycle parts. On September 5, 2016, the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence examined them at the Inland Container Depot, Tughlakabad, and allegedly found firecrackers concealed behind a small quantity of bicycle parts and pumps, and the goods were seized.
The Additional Commissioner of Customs, ICD Tughlakabad, imposed a Rs 10 lakh penalty on Goyal under Section 112(b)(i) of the Customs Act by an order of February 28, 2018, holding that his role in the import was not proved but that he knew the goods were misdeclared and had arranged a meeting between Rahul Sehgal, Saurabh Aggarwal and two Delhi-based agents. The Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT) dismissed his appeal on May 4, 2022.
The High Court found there was no evidence against Goyal except statements of co-noticees. It noted that the people with whom he had arranged the meeting were not proceeded against, and that the department’s case that Rahul Traders was the actual importer fell through when CESTAT quashed the penalty on Rahul Sehgal on August 17, 2021. It also noted that CESTAT had set aside the penalty on Saurabh Aggarwal on February 11, 2020, for want of evidence other than a co-accused’s statement.
On cross-examination, the court said Goyal had specifically asked to cross-examine Ajay Sagar, Purshottam and Jaskirat Singh, whose statements were used against him, but the request was refused and CESTAT proceeded on the wrong premise that he had not sought it. Cross-examination is not an absolute right, the Bench said, but it falls within the principles of natural justice and Section 138B of the Act.
Holding that in the absence of independent evidence, treating Goyal differently from the co-noticees could not be sustained, the court answered the substantial question of law in his favour, set aside the CESTAT order and the penalty order, and allowed the appeal.

