Delhi High Court Narrows Injunction on Rana Kapoor Biography ‘Yes Man’ to Four Statements

Date:

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has narrowed an interim injunction on the book ‘Yes Man: The Untold Story of Rana Kapoor’, holding that the restraint will apply only to the portions containing four statements found prima facie defamatory or derogatory, and not to the book as a whole. Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar passed the judgment on November 6 in appeals by publisher HarperCollins India and author Pavan Chand Lall (FAO 228/2024 and FAO 230/2024), after reserving it on August 24.

The appeals challenged a July 10, 2024 order of a Tis Hazari Courts district judge in a suit by Yes Bank co-founder and former managing director Rana Kapoor. That order restrained the sale, distribution and circulation of the book, published on December 22, 2020, while the suit is pending. Kapoor had alleged that the book, certain articles and an interview were defamatory and infringed his rights to reputation, privacy and personality.

The High Court found no reason to interfere with the trial court’s findings that Statements (iv), (vii) and (x) were defamatory and Statement (ii) derogatory. But it held that a restraint on the entire book cannot be sustained, observing that an interlocutory injunction should be no wider than necessary and that the remaining contents had not been found defamatory or derogatory at this stage. The order is modified so that the injunction operates only against the portions of the book in which those four statements occur.

The court also noted that Lall was proceeded against ex parte and did not appear before the trial court, and said that circumstance does not justify extending the injunction beyond the material on which the trial court had returned findings. It clarified that the modification is confined to interim relief and is not a final opinion on the merits or the defences, and that the trial court is to decide the suit uninfluenced by its observations. Both appeals were disposed of, with no order as to costs.

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related