Delhi High Court Declines Plea on NHRC Handling of Sukma Displacement Complaint, Says Chhattisgarh High Court Is Proper Forum

Date:

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has dismissed a petition challenging how the National Human Rights Commission (NHRC) disposed of a complaint by a Sukma, Chhattisgarh resident who said Christian Adivasi families had been displaced from their village, holding that it lacks territorial jurisdiction and that the Chhattisgarh High Court is the appropriate forum. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma pronounced the judgment in Baman Ram Kawasi v. Union of India & Anr. (W.P.(C) 13699/2026) on Thursday, after reserving it on September 18, leaving the petitioner free to pursue other remedies, including in the High Court of Chhattisgarh.

According to the petition, the petitioner and other Adivasi families of Village Chitlanar in Sukma district have practised Christianity for about 18 years. It alleged that on March 5, 2026 a mob, including local panchayat members, entered their homes and demanded that they convert to Hinduism or leave the village, that two of them were assaulted with lathis and hospitalised, that the police present did not intervene and that the families were forced to shelter in Sukma town, where they have lived in makeshift shelters since.

The petitioner said complaints were made to the police and district administration between March 6 and 12 and on May 15, 2026, and that on March 17 a mob again threatened them in the presence of police and revenue officials. These are the petitioner’s allegations as recorded in the judgment.

On June 4, 2026 the petitioner complained to the NHRC, which on June 9 disposed of the complaint by directing that it be transmitted to the concerned authorities and that the District Magistrate and the Superintendent of Police, Sukma, take appropriate action within eight weeks. The petitioner asked the High Court to treat that order only as an interim direction, keep the complaint pending before the NHRC and direct it to take fresh cognizance after a hearing, and to direct the Union of India to take steps to ensure the NHRC can discharge its mandate effectively.

The Union of India objected that the court lacks territorial jurisdiction, saying the incident, the complainants and the allegations of inaction all relate to Sukma and that the NHRC being in Delhi is not enough. It also said a petition on the same subject is pending in Chhattisgarh and had not been fully disclosed. The petitioner argued that the NHRC order challenged was passed in New Delhi, where a material part of the cause of action therefore arose.

The court held that the NHRC order does not decide any right or claim of the petitioner and merely routes the complaint back to the Sukma authorities against whom the grievance is directed, so deciding the reliefs sought would require examining events, the alleged inaction and the action taken at Sukma, where all the records are located. Neither the State of Chhattisgarh nor the Sukma District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police, who must act on the directions, had been made parties, it noted.

It also observed that if the petitioner’s argument were accepted, every NHRC order on an incident anywhere in the country could be challenged in Delhi, and cited earlier Delhi High Court rulings that the location of a decision-maker in Delhi is not by itself enough.

Even assuming that passing the order in Delhi gave rise to some part of the cause of action, the court said, the petitioner, the victims, the place of incident, the authorities and the record are all in Sukma district, and the Chhattisgarh High Court has the most direct and substantial connection with the dispute. If proceedings on the same subject are indeed pending in Chhattisgarh, entertaining this petition would risk parallel adjudication and conflicting orders, it said, while declining to return any finding on the alleged non-disclosure. The court clarified that it expressed no opinion on the merits or on the respondents’ other objections, and that all rights and contentions of the parties remain open.

Read the judgment

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related