Delhi High Court Says It Can Hear Australia-Based Couple’s Plea Against CARA Over Adopted Daughter’s NOC, Lists It for December 2

Date:

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has held that it has territorial jurisdiction to hear a petition by an adoptive couple, now citizens of Australia, seeking a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Central Adoption Resource Authority (CARA) to relocate their adopted minor daughter to Australia, rejecting an objection raised by the Union of India, the Ministry of External Affairs and the Regional Passport Officer, Amritsar. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma pronounced the judgment in Harpreet Kaur & Anr. v. Union of India & Ors. (W.P.(C) 4401/2026) on Thursday, after reserving it on September 16, and listed the petition for arguments on merits on December 2, 2026.

The petitioners are Harpreet Kaur and her husband, persons of Indian origin who are now Australian citizens holding Overseas Citizen of India cards, and their adopted daughter, who was born in Amritsar in December 2019 to relatives of the adoptive mother. The adoption ceremony was held on October 18, 2021, a deed of adoption under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 was registered at the Sub-Registrar’s office in Amritsar on November 18, 2021, and a civil court in Amritsar declared the child their adopted daughter by a judgment and decree of January 2, 2024.

The petitioners told the court that when they applied for the child’s passport in January 2022, the passport authorities declined to proceed without a CARA NOC. CARA, by a communication of August 10, 2022 from New Delhi, asked the adoptive father to follow Regulation 22C of the Adoption (Amendment) Regulations, 2021, which requires the case to be sponsored by the competent authority of the receiving country. The petitioners said the authorities in Australia declined to start that process and advised them to pursue the immigration route, for which the CARA NOC was itself needed. A March 13, 2026 representation asking CARA to place their case before its Relaxation Committee has received no response, they said.

CARA opposed the petition on merits, saying it is legally barred from issuing the NOC without the requisite approvals from the receiving country, and did not object to the court’s jurisdiction. The Union of India, the Ministry of External Affairs and the Amritsar Regional Passport Officer argued that all the material events, including the adoption deed, birth records and the passport application, took place at Amritsar, and that the location of Ministries in New Delhi does not give this court jurisdiction. They also said no passport application of the child is pending before the Amritsar office.

The court said the substance of the grievance is CARA’s non-issuance of the NOC, which the petitioners describe as the sole impediment to the child’s relocation. CARA is a statutory body at R.K. Puram, New Delhi, its August 2022 communication was issued from Delhi, the March 2026 representation was addressed to it there and remains undecided, and its stand in the counter affidavit that it cannot issue the NOC without the receiving country’s approvals is taken and maintained in Delhi. A material and integral part of the cause of action therefore arose within the court’s territorial jurisdiction under Article 226(2) of the Constitution, it held.

The court said the adoption deed, birth records and civil court decree at Amritsar are not under challenge and are only background, and that the relief sought against the Amritsar passport office is consequential, since the passport depends on the NOC. It distinguished Chintan Agrawal v. Union of India, in which the whole cause of action lay in Uttar Pradesh and the only Delhi link was the Ministry’s office. It also noted that other Delhi High Court benches have heard petitions against CARA filed by adoptive parents whose adoption deeds were executed in Punjab and Rajasthan.

Declining to send the petitioners to another High Court under the doctrine of forum conveniens, the court noted that the petition has been pending since April 2026 with pleadings complete, that CARA’s records are in New Delhi and that the matter concerns a minor child whose relocation, the petitioners say, has been pending for nearly five years. The best interests of the child must remain a paramount consideration, it said. It clarified that its observations are limited to jurisdiction and that all rights and contentions of the parties on the merits are open.

Read the judgment

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related