Delhi High Court Sets Aside Rs 50 Lakh Penalty on AM Mining India for Four-Day Delay in Stamp Duty Adjudication, Orders Collector of Stamps to Reconsider

Date:

New Delhi: The Delhi High Court on Thursday set aside a penalty of Rs 50 lakh imposed on AM Mining India Private Limited by the Collector of Stamps, Delhi, for a four-day delay in applying for adjudication of stamp duty, and directed the Collector to reconsider the matter and pass a fresh reasoned order within two months. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma passed the judgment in AM Mining India Private Limited v. Collector of Stamps, Delhi & Anr. (W.P.(C) 13257/2026).

According to the judgment, the company passed a board resolution on May 3, 2023 to issue 21,22,00,000 Class A Compulsory Convertible Preference Shares of face value Rs 10 each at a premium of Rs 32.40 per share, aggregating to Rs 899.72 crore, in favour of ArcelorMittal Nippon Steel India Limited. It filed Form PAS-3 with the Ministry of Corporate Affairs on May 4, 2023 and, on June 5, 2023, applied on its own to the Collector of Stamps in Delhi under the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 for adjudication of the stamp duty payable. The statutory period had ended on June 2, 2023, so the application was four days late.

After several hearings, the Collector imposed a penalty of Rs 50 lakh under Section 40(1)(b) of the Stamp Act on March 17, 2026, citing the four-day delay and the “time value for money”. On April 1, 2026 the High Court set that order aside because it did not explain why such a penalty was warranted, and gave the company another chance on condition that it deposit the admitted principal stamp duty of Rs 89,97,218 within 15 days. The company deposited the amount on April 23, 2026.

After a fresh hearing, the Collector passed an order dated July 2, 2026 imposing the same Rs 50 lakh penalty, and the company said it did not give credit for the stamp duty it had deposited. It then returned to the High Court seeking to quash the order and to have the Rs 89.97 lakh treated as full and final discharge of the principal stamp duty.

The court said the new order added reasons, such as the amount of government revenue involved, the absence of a satisfactory explanation and the company’s alleged continuing default, but did not explain how these justified a penalty of Rs 50 lakh. It noted that the proceedings remained pending before the Collector from June 2023 until March 2026 and that there was no finding that the company caused any of that delay, so the time taken by the authority could not be treated as the company’s default.

The court also noted that guidelines dated January 31, 2024 contemplate a penalty of 16 per cent per annum where an application is submitted voluntarily, as it was here. Even if the Collector wished to depart from the guidelines, the court said, reasons had to be recorded, and the order recorded none. It added that the order proceeded as if the company had not discharged its liability, although the principal duty had been deposited in April 2026.

Holding that the discretion under Section 40(1)(b) was not properly exercised, the court set aside the Rs 50 lakh penalty but declined to fix the penalty itself, saying that power lies with the Collector. The Collector must take into account that the company approached the authority voluntarily, the four-day delay, the time the proceedings stayed pending, the deposit of the principal duty and the 2024 guidelines, and, if any penalty is imposed, record why that amount is warranted. The company must be heard, and the Rs 89,97,218 already deposited must be credited while determining any principal duty payable.

Read the judgment

Share post:

Popular

More like this
Related